Newsweek this week pulled an anecdote out of a profile of Vice President Mike Pence by The Atlantic to insinuate that he is a hypocrite — but flat-out mischaracterized Pence’s position.

The Atlantic story contains tidbits of Pence’s colleges days, including the fact that he confessed to administrators at Hanover College that his fraternity had violated the school’s alcohol policy. Rather than take sole blame for the keg at the Phi Gamma Delta fraternity house, the future vice president got the whole house in trouble.